Shared parental pay case refused permission to appeal to Supreme Court

19 February 2020

Two joint cases which related to claims of discrimination in respect of shared parental leave allowances have been refused leave to appeal to the Supreme Court.

The cases in question were Ali v Capita and Hextall v Chief Constable of Leicestershire Police, and back in May 2019, the Court of Appeal determined that, in scenarios where enhanced shared parental pay was not aligned to match that of enhanced maternity pay, there was no sex discrimination taking place. This stance remains binding since the Supreme Court has refused permission to appeal this decision.

Capita provided its female employees with up to 39 weeks’ worth of maternity pay – the initial 14 weeks at full pay and the remaining 25 weeks at SMP rate. Mr. Ali respected that the first two weeks of maternity leave were different as the mother would need time off to recover after giving birth in this period, but argued that the remaining 12 weeks’ worth of full pay should not have been available to female employees only. He claimed that this was unlawful direct sex discrimination.

Leicester Police Force provided 18 weeks’ worth of maternity leave at full pay. They also offered a shared parental leave scheme to match statutory requirements. Mr. Hextall claimed that the employer’s policy put men at a disadvantage and was unlawful discrimination.

The Court of Appeal upheld the same response in both cases, and that was that there was no direct discrimination on a man taking shared parental leave for childcare reasons as this was not comparable to a mother who was on leave, who would require time to recover both mentally and physically after carrying and giving birth to, a child. They also maintained that there was nothing unusual about either of the company’s policies and rejected both claims.

The Supreme Court’s refusal of permission to appeal in relation to this means that employers can continue to enhance maternity pay without the requirement to enhance shared parental pay.

 


Information provided in this news article may be subject to change. Please make note of the date of publication to ensure that you are viewing up to date information. Download the CIPP's Payroll: Need to know - your guide to payroll legislation and reporting for the most up to date data.